The other movie we watched this weekend was considerably less satisfying. "Kingdom of Heaven" is director Ridley Scott's interpretation of the Crusades. First of all, Orlando Bloom is not very convincing in this film. It may be the script, direction, or maybe his androgyny gets in the way of portraying a "True Knight". His love interest, Eva Gregor as Sibylla the Queen of Jerusalem, is also not very convincing. The scenes of the siege by Saladin are entertaining and intricate, but don't seem to add much to the story line. The one convincing acting turn was Ghasson Massoud as Saladin. Within the limits of the script he managed to convey some depth to the character.
The main thing I was bothered by was the overwhelming slap at Christianity this film delivers. It protrays Christians as devious, evil, cynical and "irreligious"!! Now some of them are surely, but does the story require that the entire faith be characterized so negatively?? The Crusaders might have been a blood-thirsty lot, but they were also sincere in their belief's. They show King Baldwin as an "enlightened" king, and seeming the only "good" Christian, who tries to keep the peace by ruling fairly and treating all religions with tolerance, and all the other nobles as grasping bandits eager for blood-shed. This wouldn't be so bad if it was balanced on the Muslim side too. We only see one Muslim "bad-guy", yet the Saladin character is portrayed more evenly, not necessarily all good or all bad.
Finally the main character Balian is less than satisfying as the so-called True or Perfect Knight. First of all he kills a priest, then declares his estrangement from God, then ventures on this quest to Jerusalem to atone for his sins. Bloom is not convincing in his portrayal. He doesn't do the job like Crowe did with Maximus.
I did like Liam Neeson as the great knight Godfrey of Ibelin (Balian's/Bloom's father). He was convincing in his portrayal. I also liked the script's attempt to communicate the ideal of medieval Knighthood, what a Christian Warrior was supposed to be and what his duty was. Unfortunately the anti-Christian bias and poor portrayal by Bloom completely fails to draw a full picture of the "True Knight". The concept of chivalry and knighthood was one that was an important ideal in Christendom, regardless of how much most knights failed to achieve the ideal. The historical characters of Richard the Lion-Hearted or El Cid are important historical archetypes of the "True Knight", and it would have added a lot to this film's impact if the makers had casted a better actor for the role of Balian that could have lived up to the archetype.
I would not recommend this film as a fair treatment of the Crusades. I would recommend it for the siege scenes and some of the cinematography. Watch this film only if you've got nothing better to do.